Accidental Diarrhea/Intentional solid

[IsawpoopwasI]

What is your preference? A diarrhea accident or solid intentional? Mine is the runny accident. It seems more realistic for a panty poop to be a desperate accident rather than someone struggling to push out a solid turd. There is more sound and visual too. To each their own!

[Ellipsis]

I voted diarrhea accident, mostly because I agree with you that it's more realistic and gives more sound and visuals. You pretty much hit the nail on the head as far as I'm concerned.

[PERVasive]

Yes. I agree. Though I have to say that I find large soft desperate accidents entirely plausible and extremely sexy as well. I've certainly had some "held it too long" accidents in my time.

[DJC]

I prefer the solid. I enjoy both, but I find diarrhoea a bit too messy, and I like the naughtiness of doing something like that intentionally

[ControlFreak]

Those are the only options? What about a solid accident? That's my preference. In fact, it's just about all I'm interested. I seem to be in a small minority with this fetish, in that I'm not interested in the substance at all, just the act, so I find runny poop to be disgusting. I like deliberate naughtiness in some contexts, but mostly I like accidents, except accidents that are a result of holding it too long - accidents that have a somewhat child-like aspect - not a result of physical illness or disability.

[fastbet]

Solid

I prefer solid as well - or something in the middle. You can still hear a crackle and pop, which is nice.

[naughty norm]

diarrhea gets the nod. really soft mush feels sooo good!

[Turtlehead]

I like the idea of a solid accident. Diarrhea accidents just seem so commonplace!

The idea of a solid, or just soft, not runny, accident resulting from holding it too long or being caught short is really an exciting thought for me, whether it happens to me or to someone else, especially to a female.

A true solid accident is likely much more rare than a runny one which just squirts out. But they can and do happen. They are most likely to happen after a period of prolonged constipation, and sometimes after just waiting a very long time. At least that's been my experience, both personal and from stories I've heard.

[Victorius]

Yeah, a solid accident would do the trick for me, as well.

It has something child-like, I must admit though. With solid poo, one can probably hold on for veeeery long, if not long enough, that it gets a health issue. Therefore there's always a bit of childish "giving in" to the strong urge, a bit of willful surrendering, what makes it sexy for me.

You probably could hold on a bit more, but, what the heck: The tip is already sticking out and making a brake mark in your panties - just give a little push and let it slide out, i say.

The "doing sth childish" and braking the rules of do's and dont's of your age is always the most sexy aspect of all those fetishes to me.

(btw.: My story "Molly looses it" on the storyboard is heavily written under this aspect)

[pantiespooper]

Solid for me

There is a place for soft poop, and even 'rhea, which often does not give one time to get to the potty. It has happened to me a few times...

But I think I prefer to be constipated. When it opens me to the max (which takes a little while by itself), and then holds me there for the duration (which can be as much as 30 or 40 min), until it finally gets completely out of me --- that is the BEST!